Mark Lee Greenblatt

Author of Valor

  • home
  • book
  • Heroes
  • Bio
  • news & reviews
  • Blog
  • email a hero

Book Review: Tod Lidberg’s Heroic Heart

March 25, 2016 by Lorianne Leave a Comment

Death of the Slaying Hero: Modern egalitarian cultures can’t stomach the idea of military glory.

Mark Lee Greenblatt, Real Clear Politics, March 25, 2016
http://city-journal.org/html/death-slaying-hero-14310.html
In The Heroic Heart, Tod Lindberg explores the evolution of the heroic ideal from the ancient world to today, examining how heroes shape politics and how the political world shapes heroism. Lindberg’s “classical heroic type” describes those rare individuals willing to risk death to fulfill their own inner sense of greatness. Historical and literary examples include Achilles, Julius Caesar, and Coriolanus. Political orders adjusted to such highly individualistic, destabilizing heroes by shifting their motivations from fighting for individual glory to fighting for a greater good. “The problem of the collision of heroism and politics found a path to resolution,” Lindberg writes, “when political authorities figured out how to put a hero to use in service of their ends.”
Civilized society evolved further, emerging into a new egalitarian political order that would eventually find no place for the classical hero. Egalitarianism “is in fact designed to prevent the emergence of such a character,” Lindberg writes, lest the next Alexander the Great emerge to restore anti-democratic autocracy. The tragedies of twentieth-century history also conspired against traditional heroism. Celebrating battlefield glory became less viable after the ghastly trench warfare of World War I. The individual soldier became an antihero, Lindberg says, and war-fighting became anti-glorious.
Continue Reading...

Filed Under: Blog Tagged With: Chris Kyle, Heroic Heart, heroism, Tod Lindberg

Follow Us on RSS
Taylor Trade Publishing
224 pages
$22.95
ISBN: 978-1589799523

Now Available

Amazon
Barnes & Noble
IndieBound
Books-A-Million
Taylor Trade Publishing

Recent Posts

  • Interview with Devotion Author Adam Makos
  • Book Review: Tod Lidberg’s Heroic Heart
  • Task and Purpose: The Soldier Who Rescued His Men From An Ambush Despite A Traumatic Brain Injury
  • Military.com: Three Things I Learned About Courage From Interviewing Our Troops
  • Task & Purpose: The Marine Who Shielded His Team From A Grenade And Then Kept Fighting

Recent Comments

  • Rodrigo Albornoz.costa on Seven Years Ago Today: Monica Lin Brown
  • Emmett Spraktes on Five Years Ago Today: Emmett Spraktes
  • Rick on Ten Years Ago Today: Earl Covel
  • 9 True Stories of Iraq, Afghanistan War Heroes Chronicled in New Book on Buck Doyle
  • 9 True Stories of Iraq, Afghanistan War Heroes Chronicled in New Book on Steve Sanford

Archives

Copyright © 2019 Mark Lee Greenblatt
Terms of Service & Privacy Policy | Data Access Request